It turns out, your grandmother was right.
You can’t always believe everything you hear.
The media can be a great source for your daily news. But it’s not the best place to turn to for advice on feeding your dog. Rachael Ray’s pet food is known for being one of the better quality dog foods on the market. However, you’ll sometimes hear rumours that that the food is being recalled or contains harmful chemicals.
You’ve got questions and we’ve got answers. Read on to take a bite out of the truth behind the claim of a Rachael Ray dog food recall. And see how they stack up in our top five roundup!
Our Quick Picks
1. Rachael Ray Nutrish Super Premium Dry Dog Food– Beef, pea and rice recipe
Getting to the Bottom of The Bowl on Rumors
The three main issues you’ll hear about Rachael Ray dog food recalls are that it:
- Contains harmful chemicals
- It’s been recalled for too many vitamins in it
- That it’s on an FDA list of grain-free foods you shouldn’t feed your dog.
We’ve done all the research and the facts are in. Most of these reports are a mixture of a little fact and a whole lot of fiction.
In 2018, a claim was made that the Nutrish line of foods was part of a Rachael Ray dog food recall because it contained the harmful chemical glyphosate which is not natural. This is an herbicide used for weed control on food crops. This claim is not correct for a couple of good reasons.
First, all natural foods are ones that don’t have any added artificial coloring or flavorings. It does not mean that the ingredients are grown without the use of chemicals to control crop pests and weeds. Those food items are the ones labelled organic, which is grown without the use of these products.
Secondly, the Environmental Protection Agency has looked long and hard at the safety of glyphosate, which has been used on food since the 1970’s. It undergoes a yearly review and is not a risk to people. It’s used on everyday produce you’ll find in the supermarket, as well as wheat, barley, flax and more.
If you want to avoid glyphosate, you’ll need to look for organic dog food instead.
Currently, there is no Rachael Ray dog food recall. There was a past issue concerning a batch of cat food that has too much vitamin D in it. This same recall also affected several other pet food companies and was fixed when the new batch was released.
Last but not least, is there a Rachael Ray dog food recall on grain-free varieties?
No, but there is a link between heart problems and some dogs eating grain-free dog food. However, the problem is not caused by the food itself. All current research points a gene that makes some dogs more likely to develop the condition who don’t make enough taurine, an essential amino acid. These days, taurine is now being added to many dog foods.
What to Look For
Just like no two dogs look exactly the same, they also don’t have identical nutritional requirements. Limited ingredient diets are best for dogs that have food allergies. Puppies and older dogs have different feeding requirements than adult dogs.
In assessing these dog foods, we look at which food provides optimum nutrition for adult dogs. What we want to see:
- Whole, all natural ingredients that add extra antioxidants and vitamins.
- Most of the protein comes from real meat and not animal by-products.
- It contains essential fatty acids from fish oils and flaxseed.
- A balanced mineral content.
- Live, pup friendly probiotic cultures to support good digestion and immune function.
Our Full Reviews
Nutrish Super Premium dry dog food is a good all round choice for those that want a natural high-quality, nutritious dog food without a lot of fuss. It contains whole ground corn and brown rice in addition to USDA inspected beef.
- It is made with USDA approved farm raised beef.
- It contains peas and beet pulp, good sources of dietary fiber.
- Alfalfa nutrient extract provides an extra source of antioxidants and beta-carotene.
- There are no artificial colors or preservatives.
- A majority of dogs seem to like the flavor.
- Although this food is all natural, the ingredients are not organically grown. This means that some pesticide and herbicide are used in the farming process in accordance with the Food and Drug Administration’s guidelines.
- It may cause digestive upset if a dog is not slowly transitioned to this food over several days.
- The kibble size may be too large for tiny breeds to chew.
Just 6 is a limited ingredient dog food that might be helpful for dogs with food allergies and skin problems. It only has six ingredients in addition to a multivitamin and mineral supplement. The lamb and rice formula contains chicken fat and natural pork flavoring.
- It has only six ingredients: lamb meal, brown rice, ground rice, beet pulp, chicken fat and natural pork flavoring.
- It contains no corn, wheat or soy.
- There are no chicken or egg proteins in the formula, which can trigger food allergies.
- It is also available in a grain-free turkey and pea flavor.
- The main protein is a processed meal, which may be more digestible for some dogs.
- It has a strong, lamb-like odor that some owners may not like.
- Some dogs find limited ingredient diets boring and they won’t eat it as eagerly as they do other foods.
- This is a medium sized kibble, which may still be too large for small breeds.
SuperMedley’s Beef and Barley is a nutrient dense dog food with a rainbow of healthful ingredients. In addition to the standard base of beef and barley, they’ve added pumpkin, fish oil, berries, flaxseed, probiotics and more. The variety of ingredients gives this food a more holistic approach to overall wellness than other varieties.
- The recipe contains multiple “super foods” geared towards overall wellness.
- There are added live probiotics which can improve digestion and immune system functioning.
- It has no wheat, meat by-products, artificial colors or flavorings.
- Flaxseed and Menhaden fish oil add omega fatty acids that improve skin, coat, immune function, boost heart health and more.
- Pumpkin, berries, alfalfa extract, spinach and carrots add a host of natural vitamins and antioxidants.
- The formula may not be the best for dogs that suffer from food allergies. It contains eggs.
- Dogs that are not used to eating whole-food diets may take some time to warm up to the flavor.
- Probiotics can sometimes temporarily cause excess gas in dogs until their digestive tract get used to it.
Peak is a diet that will appeal to those that want to stick to “biologically” appropriate formulas that include raw foods. It contains freeze-dried bits of raw chicken, which eliminates harmful bacteria while preserving the benefits of raw. Ingredients include chicken, turkey and duck as main protein sources. The formula also provides added taurine and flaxseed.
- High quality, minimally processed protein sources with some freeze-dried raw meat added.
- Only other ingredients are beet pulp, flaxseed, peas, pea protein, pea starch, sweet potatoes and chicken fat.
- The size is small enough that many miniature breeds will be able to eat it.
- It has added taurine.
- There are no meat by-products, junk fillers, or unhealthy grains.
- It is a high protein, calorie dense food that may not be good for dogs that are overweight and don’t get much exercise.
- Fussy eaters may push aside the kibble and try to only eat the raw bites.
- Because of the ingredients and special processing, this dog food is slightly more expensive than other options.
What makes Dish different from Nutrish Super Premium Beef are the extra ingredients, such as cranberries, Menhaden fish oil, dried apples, flaxseed and potatoes. The kibble is also separated into individual flavors so it looks more like a homemade meal.
- The main protein sources are beef and chicken meal.
- It has three sources of essential fatty acids from flaxseed, fish oil and sunflower oil.
- It has a variety of ingredients that are a natural source of antioxidants.
- This formula contains brewer’s rice, which some people feel is a cheap by-product that offers no value. However, this is not true. Studies show that brewer’s rice is easily digested and may actually help reduce liver damage.
- Not every dog loves the carrot pieces and may spit them out onto the floor.
- The recipe does contain brown sugar and there’s no listing on the label as to how much sugar is in the formula.
- The number of vegetable pieces may not be the same in every bag.
Our pick for the best overall grub not involved in any Rachael Ray dog food recall is:
The Tail End
While all of the foods on our list contain premium ingredients, Super Medleys stand out head and tails above the rest for the thoughtful combination of wholesome nutrition.
The protein content gets a boost from additional sources of meat, including beef, fishmeal and eggs. Barley and brown rice are both a better choice of energy-producing grains than corn or wheat.
The addition of pumpkin, spinach, blueberries, carrots and peas add extra antioxidants and vitamins. The extra essential fatty acids from flaxseed and fish oil, plus the addition of live probiotics, means that you’re getting more nutritional punch than the average bag of dog food provides.